pratheekrebala
Joined 10 years ago
Joined 10 years ago
However, it adds enough friction (especially with remote work) that it's hard to get it right 100% of the time.
If you want to share really sensitive documents, one way to ensure proper handling of your documents is to use a service like SecureDrop [0] which for e.g. only accepts submissions over Tor and requires the use of a secure viewing station [1] (air-gapped machine live-booting Tails w coreboot rom + webcam/networking card physically removed) to decrypt/access leaks.
That being said, I don't think there's a perfect tech-only solution because nothing is stopping folks handling it carelessly after they access the file.
[0] https://securedrop.org/directory/center-public-integrity/
I think being responsive to their needs and building trust will go much further. Also, designing a one-size fits all model will just mean that your reporters will either ignore the guidance or find a way to work around it.
For instance, the most recent credible threat we have had against one of our reporters wasn't a state-level actor, but rather folks on the internet (trivially) finding their address and doxing/harassing them and their family. No amount of technology hygiene will change the fact that voter registrations are public records.
A woman was detained at Philadelphia International Airport on her return from Punta Cana. After a few hours (~7hrs) of questioning she is pressured to sign a consent form, denied a consultation with an attorney and forcefully shackled and transferred to a hospital for a "monitored bowel movement" (This involves defecating in the presence of a CBP officer; No warrant needed).
She was then involuntarily committed to the hospital for "elevated heart rate" where she was forcefully stripped, underwent a "close visual inspection", administered lorazepam and olanzapine through IV, underwent an X-Ray, CT Scan along with a urine and blood workup - all of which came back negative for drugs or other contraband.
This entire ordeal lasted nearly 24 hours. After which, she was taken back to the airport and released to drive home. During her drive from the airport, she crashes into a highway median. She alleges that the she wasn't advised about the adverse effects of the medications being used to sedate her and that the medication was responsible for the accident.
All of this happened to a U.S. Citizen; without a warrant and without permission to call a lawyer.
This incident is discussed in further detail in the 4th section of the story mentioned earlier [1] "Invasive Searches: A woman's 24-hour ordeal"
[1] https://publicintegrity.org/immigration/shocked-and-humiliat...
> Legal precedents grant federal officers at ports of entry the power, without warrants, to require people to strip for a “visual inspection” of genitals and rectums, and to submit to a “monitored bowel movement” to check for secreted drugs.[1]
We did a deep-dive on court settlements by CBP for invasive searches and found quite a few extremely disturbing cases.[1]
> Some women were also handcuffed and transported to hospitals where, against their will, they underwent pelvic exams, X-rays and in one case, drugging via IV, according to suits. Invasive medical procedures require a detainee’s consent or a warrant. In two cases, women were billed for procedures
[1] "‘Shocked & Humiliated’: Lawsuits accuse Customs, Border Officers of invasive searches of minors, women." ( https://publicintegrity.org/immigration/shocked-and-humiliat... )
But they are hardly the only player, we were interested in not only identifying how far these known model bills are going but also surface bills from groups we don't know about!
Also, not all model bills are necessarily malicious - we found hundreds of bills that were almost identical but were just trying to standardize things like how we license nurses or other healthcare practitioners.
This project was basically an all-pairs text similarity problem. We were able to identify a lot of copycat legislation addressing a wide range of issues from e-cigarettes and prescription opiods to online sports betting, "religious freedom" and undocumented immigration. Some from previously known groups like ALEC and others from previously unknown interest groups.
We also have a public facing tool in the works that would allow anyone to track such measures in near real-time. We will be launching the tool and open sourcing the code in the coming weeks!
Also, do check out our launch story in this series about one such model bill that would allow car dealers to resell cars with active recalls. And keep an eye out for more stories about model legislation!
https://publicintegrity.org/state-politics/copy-paste-legisl...