walkingriver
Joined 6 years ago
Joined 6 years ago
Each PR gets two reviewers from pullrequest.com, and we get to see each others' comments. One will catch stuff the other misses, and we usually support each other. It's most fascinating when we disagree on something, which so far has always led to a high-quality discussion between the engineers and the reviewers.
I've been working with them for most of 2021, and I can honestly say I'm impressed with the review comments I have seen. It's been nothing but respectful and professional. As a plus, it's made me a better code reviewer at my day job.
During my code reviews, which tend to revolve around Angular and Ionic (that's what I signed up for), I have found lots of outdated practices. I can often provide advice on how to make their code better, show them features that are deprecated and how to address them, and generally make their code better.
As another reviewer has pointed out, we can see the entire code base, not just the current diff. We tend to work with the same companies repeatedly and become familiar their project. Some of the engineering teams treat us as part of their team and ask for advice, which is really cool.
Doing code reviews for pullrequest.com has also made me a better reviewer in my day job and has changed the way I approach my coworkers. It's truly been a win-win.
So I would say, "yes."