timlatim

In Windows reviews [1], 285K's performance is even worse, particularly in gaming tests where it is slower than 14900K and 7800X3D (and with AMD soon launching 9800X3D, the gap should become even bigger). Just like Zen 5 on its launch, Arrow Lake seems to suffer from scheduling issues. As the linked review notes, "When pairing Windows 24H2 with Arrow Lake, performance will be terrible—we've seen games running at 50% the FPS vs 23H2". So there's some hope for improvement with future updates, but overall the Windows scheduler looks beyond suboptimal for modern CPUs with complex topology.

Just to offer a different point of view, I see it as the opposite. I like a lot of things the KDE community is doing and I think it's particularly good at power user oriented apps like Krita and Kdenlive, which may be the best open-source tools in their respective areas and which don't really fit in the modern Gnome framework. As a desktop environment, however, I feel KDE is too visually chaotic to be usable. This post [1] illustrates some problems, but the lack of design cohesion permeates KDE and cannot be fixed without a long concerted effort. I imagine it's never been a priority because most users can shrug these inconsistencies off as something inconsequential, but for me (and I don't believe I'm alone in this) they're instantly noticeable and distracting eyesores.

Gnome has its own problems, but it is very visually consistent and clean, especially as of late when most of the standard apps are moved to GTK4/libadwaita. The GP's comparison of KDE being closer in spirit to Windows while Gnome to Mac is spot on IMO.

Compared to that, search in the start menu (or Windows Explorer for that matter) is so comically bad it makes me weep. Before I knew about Everything, I could maybe believe there is something about NTFS or Windows security or whatever that makes it impossible to do fast quality search across the filesystem in modern Windows. But no, it's clearly possible, and it's such a shame that Microsoft is incapable of doing that in its own OS.

While the less-than-stellar reviews for the 9950X are already out, AMD's recent strategy of staggering releases for desktop parts (first the regular, then the X3D SKUs) can improve this generation's perception, assuming there are meaningful performance gains they can reach in software for Zen 5 prior to the X3D release.