shoyer
Joined 13 years ago
Joined 13 years ago
AST parsing via reflection means your ML compiler needs to re-implement all of Python, which is not a small language. This is a lot of work and hard to do well with abstractions that are not designed for those use-cases. (I believe Julia's whole language auto-diff systems struggle for essential the same reason.)
One nit on your framing: NeuralGCM (https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-024-07744-y), built by my team at Google, is currently at the top of the WeatherBench leaderboard and actually builds in lots of physics :).
We would love to metrics from your model in WeatherBench for comparison. When/if you have that, please do reach out.
Finding a good mentor -- someone whose values you agree with and who sets you up for career success -- is far more important than working on any particular topic of interest. The world is full of interesting research topics, and very few PhDs work in the precise area of their PhD research for their entire career.
This article also misses what is likely the leading interpretation of quantum mechanics by actual quantum physicists, namely that the measurment problem is solved by decoherence (the quantitative theory of how classical states emerge from quantum states):
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Measurement_problem#The_role_o...
https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rsta.2011.049...
Exmaple: I got divorced last year. Betterment took weeks of time and many phones calls until they were able to figure out a way to divide our assets evenly, without a large difference in cost basis. Their automatic algorithm for dividing accounts just didn't know how to handle it.
If UBS figures out how to offer a higher level of service on top of robo-advising, that could be a real win.
We'll believe it when it happens.
I also contribute to open source projects in the scientific Python stack (xarray, pandas, dask, numpy).
http://stephanhoyer.com