gpvos

Joined 15 years ago

Karma
8,540
Submissions
3,812
Member since
Jun 30
1971, Netherlands
View on Hacker News

Recent submissions

Comment · 2 days ago
There is also the issue of recognition software that doesn't have too many false positives, and properly tuning it for each crossing, in all light situations. The amount of time and work needed can really be very large. I'm not against it though. Some pilot projects would be a good idea.
Comment · 2 days ago
My thoughts as well. It appears that such signal failures happen so often that the controllers regularly let trains run through red under verbal authorization. I don't know the exact protocols, but I would expect a driver to ask for confirmation, as happened here, and then trust the control centre. However, there is clearly a huge systemic problem, with added complexity for the controllers, and there should at least be double checks in the control centre.
Comment · 3 days ago
In common parlance, "high-speed train" refers to the type of train, not their current speed.
Comment · 3 days ago
Depending on where, there can be lots and lots of small crossings. The cameras themselves might not be that expensive, but keeping them in working order is very nontrivial.
Comment · 3 days ago
Train controllers (dispatchers, signallers) existed way before liberalization.

There is merit to your arguments, but I still don't think it's the main issue in this case.

Comment · 3 days ago
Comment · 3 days ago
By now, I'd ask which short-distance trains...
Comment · 3 days ago
"Directly" is way too strong. Yes, it may have been a factor here that the train that remained standing still was from another operator, but there are many more important factors at play, the main one being apparent lack of safety mindset of the controller. In other European countries with even more operators, the safety record is not commensurably worse.
Comment · 3 days ago
Proper training focuses specifically on those exceptional situations (like it does for airplane pilots), with strong emphasis on always falling back on safe procedures. Even so, you can't cover 100% of possibilities.
Comment · 3 days ago
When on verbal authorization, controller discipline is probably more important than driver discipline. And I really hope they don't do that at 300 km/h.
Comment · 3 days ago
Comment · 3 days ago
64 already. Those trains are quite long and sturdy. But there will be lots of severely wounded.
Comment · 3 days ago
That is an interesting factoid, thanks.
Comment · 3 days ago
As far as I know, the discussion is ongoing and H. neanderthalensis is still a current classification. But yes, the consensus is moving in the direction you describe.

We'll probably never know how they were perceived in society back then, if it was e.g. like Asians versus westerners now.

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton