golden_apples
Joined 15 years ago
Joined 15 years ago
The paper details 30 companies investigated and found lacking, but no mention of how extensive the survey was. Was every single company they looked at in violation? Did they check out 100 companies and find 30 that didn't comply?
It would be nice to be able to highlight a name, search for it in this database, and play an audio file from a browser extension, for example. Or from an email client, or a linkedin profile, or wherever. Having to visit this site to look up a name is enough of a barrier that once the novelty wears off, I can't see it being too well used.
I get that you're trying to take a cheap shot, but that wasn't the story as I remember reading it. There was bitterness about the "meritocracy" meme from a lot of people in tech who felt that it discounted their marginalized status. JAH ran into that response while trying to do outreach for the Passion Projects series, and relayed it back to the Github leadership, who responded respectfully.
There's a more complete retelling of that issue here: http://readwrite.com/2014/01/24/github-meritocracy-rug
>> Horvath and other women at GitHub began to feel as if they were “bearing the brunt” of the rug’s message as well as “being excluded from other communities as a result.”
>> One employee, Horvath says, thought she was rejected for membership in Double Union, a feminist hackerspace, because of the rug. Double Union did parody the rug on its crowdfunding page, but denied that it would reject a possible member because of the rug.
ie, not necessarily related to the exact situation at github, but referring to a situation at another company.
http://www.vice.com/en_ca/read/cowards-are-blackmailing-youn...
Its an issue of protecting users who are using apps like these believing their privacy is safeguarded.
Whether this problem can be fixed with a technological solution, rather than a more dramatic social change, is doubtful, but since the can of worms has been opened, its worth trying.
There was a short-lived trend in design a few years back that used the term ”maximalism” to mean something similar - covering every surface, layering metaphors on top of metaphors, mixing traditions from all over.
Twitter, in addition to being a genuinely interesting social phenomenon, has always posed technical challenges that were sufficiently interesting to attract some top-notch people. Give them the respect of judging them by their technical work, and not their employer's latest unpopular business decision.
I'd be really curious to see how a present day retelling if the story would handle this disconnect.
This technique could be used for evil very easily.