dsifry

Joined 18 years ago

Karma
87
Submissions
38
Member since
May 30
Founder of Warmstart, Technorati, Offbeat Guides, Sputnik, Linuxcare, former exec at Reddit and Lyft. Entrepreneur, geek, photographer, dad.
View on Hacker News

Recent submissions

Comment · 3 months ago
Comment · 3 months ago
Comment · 8 months ago
Comment · 9 months ago
Some github comments are marked as sctionable, some have threads and suggestions, some are suggestions or are nitpicks. This provides you with a deterministic, reliable red/green approach that you cn use to enforce your policy. Give it a try and you will see how it is much more reliable than using a nondeterministic agent, especially for complex reviews!
Comment · 9 months ago
Yeah, it is about making sure that EVERY actionable PR comment gets addressed - whwther by fixing, resolving, creating a new issue, commenting that it is a will not fix, or blocking for human review - and then giving you a clear deterministic check you can do to reliably enforce your policy.
Comment · 9 months ago
Just to be clear - the hook is deterministic, but the subagent running with an mcp server loaded is not - and for medium/large PRs, it can run out of context window or just forget what it is trying to do and get lazy and say 'Everything is good, ready to merge!' when in fact tests are failing or there are still unaddressed PR comments.
Comment · 9 months ago
I found that it has improved overall code quality significantly, at the cost of somewhat slower velocity. But it has meant fewer interruptions where the ai is just waiting for me, or saying "Everything is ready!" only to find that ci/cd failed or there were clearly existing comments/issues.
Comment · 9 months ago
Lol, I thought it did a reasonably good job, but to each their own - this was the difference between releasing the project so others could use it with decent documentation, or not releasing and just using it internally. :)
Comment · 9 months ago
Exactly right!

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton