dbaron
Joined 17 years ago
Joined 17 years ago
Many (but not all) of us believe that same-origin by default is also the right thing for security, that it should be the default for new types of resource linking on the Web, and that not having same origin restrictions for things like images was a pretty serious mistake that we're still paying the security costs of (for example, with canvas image tainting).
(And, given the context of what the group is trying to do -- build a do-not-track mechanism that advertisers are willing to honor -- I agree that it's obvious.)
Personally, I'm stumped by the "without anything passing in writing" part, which seems to me to make the problem unnecessarily harder, since Pandarus was carrying codes for them printed on silk (to be sewn into the lining of clothing).
And... since I haven't mentioned it already: this is a great book. It's gripping, and reads a little bit like a movie for a good reason -- its author (who is telling the story of his experiences working on cryptography during the war in his early 20s) went on to become a screenwriter.
(This is particularly bad when I open a large number of articles in tabs, to read later.)
My main point wasn't so much about the magnitude of the taxes, but about the shape of the graph. Most of what gives this graph its bizarre shape is a result of the federal laws, not state ones; I just happened to be computing for a California resident because that's where I live, so I had the tax forms in front of me. (And it's also the largest state by population.)
(I'd also note that state-to-state comparisons of taxes aren't really fair without adding local taxes too, since different states have different relationships between the amount of money spent by the state government and local governments. In California, specifically, it's very hard to raise local (property) taxes, so much of education funding comes from the state government. In many states, education would be funded much more by local taxes.)