amanjaincorp

Joined 6 years ago

Karma
85
Submissions
19
Member since
Jul 23
https://amanjain.substack.com/about
View on Hacker News

Recent submissions

Comment · 1 year ago
Comment · 1 year ago
Comment · 5 years ago
Comment · 6 years ago
Why would you expect more experience than implied on the article?
Comment · 6 years ago
Is there anything we can do as a community to prevent this?
Comment · 6 years ago
RE: What failed?

Agreed this is a problem that your product needs to solve either way. This idea validation playbook allows you to face the problem early on as opposed to later.

RE: What happens when you're building an improved version?

I'd ask you why you think yours is an improved version? Is that a sure shot fact or up for the market to decide. If it's sure shot, they yeah skip the idea validation step. Sounds like your idea has more execution risk than market risk.

But if you think its subjective, then that's probably something you could find a creative way of solving using the Painted Door test or something similar.

Comment · 6 years ago
That's a really interesting idea!
Comment · 6 years ago
Poll of "fellow FB employees" could be replaced with spending ~$100 on Google Ads and using a certain targeting criteria.
Comment · 6 years ago
I love that book. Such a tiny book but so much wisdom.
Comment · 6 years ago
Comment · 6 years ago
I agree different levels of "skin in the game" mean different signal.

Simple link click is pretty lousy signal and I would ignore it.

I think email is okay. Phone number is probably better. Somebody putting their credit card is really good.

I didn't mention all of that for brevity. But you could device a point based grading system based on what signal you get.

Comment · 6 years ago
From my experience, the FB brand will get you user entering the door. I agree that's an advantage.

But the FB brand does not get your app Product Market Fit.

Those people who entered the door because of the ads $ spent, leave and then don't come back.

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton