Comment

Comment by nkurz

No one can see X-rays (or infrared, or ultraviolet, or microwaves). It doesn't matter how much a person believes he can. Retinas simply don't have the sensory hardware.

The author seems to have stumbled into a poor example, as a recent study shows that humans can indeed see infrared light using an unexpected process. Should we read anything into the audio case from this? Probably not, but it's a sign that even those who are sure they are right because they have science on their side should retain some degree of openmindedness.

  Human infrared vision is triggered by two-photon chromophore isomerization

  This study resolves a long-standing question about the   
  ability of humans to perceive near infrared radiation (IR) 
  and identifies a mechanism driving human IR vision. A few 
  previous reports and our expanded psychophysical studies 
  here reveal that humans can detect IR at wavelengths longer 
  than 1,000 nm and perceive it as visible light, a finding 
  that has not received a satisfactory physical explanation. 
  We show that IR light activates photoreceptors through a 
  nonlinear optical process. IR light also caused 
  photoisomerization of purified pigments and a model 
  chromophore compound. These observations are consistent  
  with our quantum mechanical model for the energetics of 
  two-photon activation of rhodopsin. Thus, humans can 
  perceive IR light via two-photon isomerization of visual 
  pigment chromophores.
http://www.pnas.org/content/early/2014/11/25/1410162111
parent nkurz 12 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton