> I'm baffled that you find the mechanics of human motivation hard to understand, (presumably ;) being a human yourself.
But that’s exactly it! The mathematicians are framing this as being bad for human understanding of math, but it’s obviously really about their own motivations for developing that understanding! Which, again, goes back to the obvious conclusion that what they have lost is the extrinsic motivation for being first, not the intrinsic motivation of developing understanding.
That is totally fine! I wouldn’t be motivated to do my job if I wasn’t extrinsically rewarded for doing so. But I am also not feeding anyone a line of BS about how it’s actually some other higher-minded motivation driving my work.
I’m empathetic to the instability of the extrinsic rewards for doing math research as a profession in the current moment. I am not at all empathetic to an attempt to manipulate me into thinking that the real problem is something other than that.
It’s like an entrepreneur complaining that they can’t build a business that would better humanity because of high taxes. That’s fine - but the motivation lacking there is obviously making money, not bettering humanity.
But that’s exactly it! The mathematicians are framing this as being bad for human understanding of math, but it’s obviously really about their own motivations for developing that understanding! Which, again, goes back to the obvious conclusion that what they have lost is the extrinsic motivation for being first, not the intrinsic motivation of developing understanding.
That is totally fine! I wouldn’t be motivated to do my job if I wasn’t extrinsically rewarded for doing so. But I am also not feeding anyone a line of BS about how it’s actually some other higher-minded motivation driving my work.
I’m empathetic to the instability of the extrinsic rewards for doing math research as a profession in the current moment. I am not at all empathetic to an attempt to manipulate me into thinking that the real problem is something other than that.
It’s like an entrepreneur complaining that they can’t build a business that would better humanity because of high taxes. That’s fine - but the motivation lacking there is obviously making money, not bettering humanity.