Lawyer here. Thisis correct but it highlights an important aspect if the thing that I am actively trying to pursue.
Garbage in, garbage out. Right, everyone knows this.
So, my question is, if I redline a document, I don't just see what's there but also what is missing.
Ai generally only work with what's avoailavle and unless you specifcally ask for it, it wont question it.
Take a rental agreement for example. I have tested this before, gave a redlining task whatever, and the draft did not have either a start date clause or a period Claude and none flagged it.
A lawyer would find this easily.
What I am trying to say is, among other things, you get a DMCA notice for example and you use Claude to file a reply, it will find all the proper citations, statutes, etc but if the other side didnt invoke a point, Claude will have no way to object to that because it isn't in the notice.
That is my only issue.
The problem compounds, if a person later reviews it, they skim over because they expect other people to have done their job first....
Garbage in, garbage out. Right, everyone knows this.
So, my question is, if I redline a document, I don't just see what's there but also what is missing. Ai generally only work with what's avoailavle and unless you specifcally ask for it, it wont question it.
Take a rental agreement for example. I have tested this before, gave a redlining task whatever, and the draft did not have either a start date clause or a period Claude and none flagged it.
A lawyer would find this easily.
What I am trying to say is, among other things, you get a DMCA notice for example and you use Claude to file a reply, it will find all the proper citations, statutes, etc but if the other side didnt invoke a point, Claude will have no way to object to that because it isn't in the notice.
That is my only issue.
The problem compounds, if a person later reviews it, they skim over because they expect other people to have done their job first....