>You can do that, but then you’re no longer discussing his predictions. You’re discussing your predictions, and your own positioning.
Depends if you care about the "prediction" part or if you care about the assessment of the situation (regardless of date).
If someone in 2000 said "the subprime mortgages market is a bubble and will blow no later than 2003", they got the prediction wrong, but their assessment would be right.
Depends if you care about the "prediction" part or if you care about the assessment of the situation (regardless of date).
If someone in 2000 said "the subprime mortgages market is a bubble and will blow no later than 2003", they got the prediction wrong, but their assessment would be right.