Comment

Comment by mattlondon

We use the various instruction .md files for the agents and update them with common issues and pitfalls to avoid, as well as pointers to the coding standards doc.

Gemini and Claude at least seem to work well with it, but sometimes still make mistakes (e.g. not using c++ auto is a recurrent thing, even though the context markdown file clearly states not to). I think as the models improve and get better at instruction handling it will get better.

Not saying this is "the solution" but it gets some of the way.

I think we need to move away from "vibe coding", to more caring about the general structure and interaction of units of code ourselves, and leave the AI to just handle filling in the raw syntax and typing the characters for us. This is still a HUGE productivity uplift, but as an engineer you are still calling the shots on a function by function, unit by unit level of detail. Feels like a happy medium.

parent mattlondon 1 year ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton