Yes, I'm literally talking about this sentence: "host, who knows what’s behind the doors, opens another door, say #3, which has a goat."
I parsed that as "50% of the time, monty opens another door and it has a car and you win immediately, and 50% of the time, monty opens another door and it has a goat". In retrospect I think my brain just sort of pictured that and proceeded to assume there was no reason to switch, and it wasn't until I read some answers (not her explanation) that I understood I was wrong (and I went through a lot of anger, like many of the commenters, and thought she was very wrong before that).
If there had been exactly one more sentence saying "monty always opens a door showing a goat", I'm pretty sure I would have recognized that. BTW I was familiar with the game (I liked Jeopardy better, as Let's Make a Deal was a fairly dull show) and I don't think they had a game that was identical to the problem as described.
I parsed that as "50% of the time, monty opens another door and it has a car and you win immediately, and 50% of the time, monty opens another door and it has a goat". In retrospect I think my brain just sort of pictured that and proceeded to assume there was no reason to switch, and it wasn't until I read some answers (not her explanation) that I understood I was wrong (and I went through a lot of anger, like many of the commenters, and thought she was very wrong before that).
If there had been exactly one more sentence saying "monty always opens a door showing a goat", I'm pretty sure I would have recognized that. BTW I was familiar with the game (I liked Jeopardy better, as Let's Make a Deal was a fairly dull show) and I don't think they had a game that was identical to the problem as described.