Love this! I regularly hit the minus button on the top comment to see what the next top-level comment is. Your interface shows me the most popular top-level comments so I can choose from among them. That's great!
A couple thoughts:
• I can't tell what the hashtag button is for
• The numbers in the lower right corner of each stack seem like they refer to the number of sub-comments, but in my brief experience this doesn't seem to be the case. Is this a bug, of have I misunderstood what these numbers refer to?
• I'd prefer to be able to tap a comment stack and have it open up. I get that swiping isn't that hard, but I typically one-hand and would prefer if mere tapping did the same thing as swiping (and I can't think of what else a tap would mean, so it shouldn't cause a conflict to have this as an option, right?)
• There's no way to reach the settings from the discussion view. The presence of a ... icon makes this confusing, because that's where I'd expect to be able to change settings and such. I would suggest adding Settings to this menu, as an alternate way of reaching it.
I know some people are upset about the freemium model, but I think you threaded the needle just about right here. You don't actually disable the night mode functionality in free mode — you just make it not a permanent setting. It would be slightly better if you were more explicit about when the temporary setting will expire, but I really don't see how someone can complain about how you've done this. You let people access every single functionality so they can try it out. Unless you're making this a pure hobby (in which case there would be less upkeep, support, and ongoing development), you can't rely on a tip jar.
A couple thoughts:
• I can't tell what the hashtag button is for
• The numbers in the lower right corner of each stack seem like they refer to the number of sub-comments, but in my brief experience this doesn't seem to be the case. Is this a bug, of have I misunderstood what these numbers refer to?
• I'd prefer to be able to tap a comment stack and have it open up. I get that swiping isn't that hard, but I typically one-hand and would prefer if mere tapping did the same thing as swiping (and I can't think of what else a tap would mean, so it shouldn't cause a conflict to have this as an option, right?)
• There's no way to reach the settings from the discussion view. The presence of a ... icon makes this confusing, because that's where I'd expect to be able to change settings and such. I would suggest adding Settings to this menu, as an alternate way of reaching it.
I know some people are upset about the freemium model, but I think you threaded the needle just about right here. You don't actually disable the night mode functionality in free mode — you just make it not a permanent setting. It would be slightly better if you were more explicit about when the temporary setting will expire, but I really don't see how someone can complain about how you've done this. You let people access every single functionality so they can try it out. Unless you're making this a pure hobby (in which case there would be less upkeep, support, and ongoing development), you can't rely on a tip jar.