Comment

Comment by CM30

Have to be honest, I've always thought complaints about trademarked products in works of fiction were a silly thing to begin with. Why shouldn't a fictional universe feature products and businesses found in the real world? Are we supposedly to randomly assume all other universes don't have humvees or macbooks or the Red Cross? Who's to say the same people/companies/organisations would even be responsible in that work of fiction?

The law should basically just say there's no trademark violation in featuring a real world product/service in a fictional work so long as it couldn't reasonably be confused as a piece of marketing by the creator of said product or person. Obviously the work shouldn't be about say, Mickey Mouse, but it should be perfectly fine to feature say, Disney and their products as background elements in a fictional work without the approval of Disney.

Just seems ridiculous to have it work any other way.

parent CM30 6 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton