No. Tests are like any other code. They incur technical debt and bugs at the same rate as other code. They also introduce friction to the development process. As your test suite grows, your dev process often begins to slow down unless you apply additional work to grease the wheels, which is yet another often unmeasured cost of testing in this fashion.
So, in short, I view tests as a super useful, but over-applied tool. I want my tests to deliver high enough value to warrant their ongoing maintenance and costs. That means I don't write nearly as many tests as I used to (in my own projects), and far fewer than my peers.
Where I work, tests are practically mandated for everything, and a full CI run takes hours, even when distributed across 20 machines. Anecdotally, I've worked for companies that test super heavily, and I've worked for companies that had no automated tests at all. (They tested manually before releases.) The ratio of production issues across all of my jobs is roughly flat.
This issue tends to trigger people. It's like religion or global warming or any other hot-button issue. It would be interesting to try to come up with some statistical analysis of the costs / benefit of automated tests.
So, in short, I view tests as a super useful, but over-applied tool. I want my tests to deliver high enough value to warrant their ongoing maintenance and costs. That means I don't write nearly as many tests as I used to (in my own projects), and far fewer than my peers.
Where I work, tests are practically mandated for everything, and a full CI run takes hours, even when distributed across 20 machines. Anecdotally, I've worked for companies that test super heavily, and I've worked for companies that had no automated tests at all. (They tested manually before releases.) The ratio of production issues across all of my jobs is roughly flat.
This issue tends to trigger people. It's like religion or global warming or any other hot-button issue. It would be interesting to try to come up with some statistical analysis of the costs / benefit of automated tests.