Comment

Comment by tannhaeuser

> It's complex because it does a complex work

Hence it's pointless because it doesn't make things any simpler. All it does is making things monolithic and wrapping concepts that are perfectly fine by themselves, forcing third-party software to write to systemd's APIs.

> Systemd actually does ONE thing and does it well: it manages the system.

"Managing systems" is not what is meant by "doing one thing, and doing it well". Systemd takes over init scripting, logging, host names, IP, time, locale, and login, plus tens of more services. Making development of this software a Lennart Poettering/RH-only business rather than community-driven.

The trend to get rid of systemd and its metastasis into most of Linux is excellent news. Note that Slackware and Devuan are also systemd-free (and have been from the beginning).

parent tannhaeuser 7 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton