philipp2310
Joined 4 years ago
Joined 4 years ago
Regarding "just to pay some celebrity".. well, that is currently way out of our budget, as everything offered so far is 100% free and there are no plans to change that :)
To be fair: Project Alice is older than yandex Alice and there is nothing but the name connecting these two assistants!
Currently you got the following choice: Pico, Mycroft, Google Standard/Wavenet, Amazon, IBM Watson
And while using one of the cloud variants might cause security concerns, keep in mind, they will only know what to speak, not why (e.g. what your input/request was)
I came to the conclusion, there are so many car stickers/unlicensed merch or even companies with a similar logo, there shouldn't be an issue for a small open source project. Maybe a dangerous conclusion, that should be revised when Alice grows :)
Another thing to keep in mind is, we use intermediate results for the ASR. Means already while you are speaking, the input is parsed. Only a few ms after you go silent, the parsing is finalized and NLU/TTS will start right away.
Of course with a bit bias, I'd say it is more like: "Hey Alice" "Yes?.." "What's gonna be the weather at 11 tomorrow?" short pause (.2 seconds?) <answer>
Another option, if you are a bit more open with "sharing" data and you don't want to miss out the best TTS, is enabling google or azure cloud services - with the big difference, Alice will only send the sound right after detecting your hotword (only while flashing her LED and asking you "yes?" before the recording starts). Nothing else would be shared.
I put it up for discussion. We don't want to cling to our current design, but we aren't sure yet about a good way to approach a redesigns. Needs a bit time to decide what aspects of Alice in total should be redesigned