karmicthreat
Joined 14 years ago
Joined 14 years ago
Recently Radu over at Galvano.ai let me beta his platform. Way farther and way faster than anything I have used so far. Even managed to make the schematic placement sane.
The actual project was a regen clamp. So if the output voltage is greater than the input voltage (back emf from motor) you divert the excess to a resistor.
This has some analog tuning needed. So I created a python and skidl mirror of the netlist. This mirror was used to create ngspice unit tests to drive component optimization. Turns out not every resistor needed to be .1% and the ESR of our storage caps was a critical value.
All in all, it’s like ai and software. It’s not going to replace every job but will change how the jobs are done.
The product just grinds tokens for little return, in my opinion. I had far better luck wiring together KiCad MCP, SKIDL. There are some AI-driven autorouters out there now. Placement is probably the big issue that needs to be solved now. I could only get about 80% of what I wanted together with my hacky workflow.
Most of my curiosity is tempered by how it can make me money.
I do appreciate that 50-70% of the boring work can be done with AI agents now. As long as you know enough to have opinions and guide the process along, it can be helpful.
Expertise and learning don't seem to be AS important with the upcoming gen of developers. However, there is also so much out there now that it would be much harder to start from zero as opposed to being there from the beginning.
But I think gen X and Millenials were probably peak interest and curiosity, now it's just a job for the later generations.
I've run the project through cline and roo. Also tried Claude 3.7 and the 1M context Gemni 2.5 pro model. I'd say Gemini is less creative. But it's still good.
I can see how it is a productivity booster. Or at least it gives you the illusion of one. Really I think best part of it is just building out detailed documentation. That's really the killer app for me.
It can be a bit difficult to get going on a specific platform, but once you have it going, it's smooth sailing.
[ my public key: https://keybase.io/karmicthreat; my proof: https://keybase.io/karmicthreat/sigs/ttAGGnZVRE3IOjY_P_pSNvljde_QbjJxez9D8XwTSzE ]