cnd78A

People who have spent time in these areas (not as tourists) often notice the hugely damaging effects of many charities. If Western societies had relied on charity in pre-industrial times, they might never have been forced to develop strong institutions and welfare systems. Instead, they might have evolved into begging cultures.

These systems are incredibly difficult to develop because doing so goes against our selfish nature. In Tanzania, across Africa, and in many other parts of the world, people often care only about their own circle—in other words, their own family and kin.

I do believe wealth should be shared. It shouldn't be a choice; it should be an obligation. But not like this.

The ultimate goal of charities should not be to enrich individuals, but to help them build cooperative societies capable of supporting the most vulnerable.

I believe your donation only makes the problem worse. Helping people is much harder than simply giving money to someone in a way that makes you feel good about yourself—without even getting into the many Western NGO workers who profit from posts like this.

The problem is that this is an extremely difficult step to achieve, because it does not simply depend on the will of the people. It depends on cultural evolution. Human beings are not naturally rational; like other species, we are driven by evolutionary processes that are often irrational and self-interested.

Most countries—and, more specifically, the majority of their citizens—have not yet reached this stage of civilizational development. The French are far from it, and I believe the Germans are as well. Despite belonging to the generation that emerged from a relatively recent period of cultural barbarism, Germany is currently supporting what is considered as the greatest genocide and one of the gravest sets of war crimes of our time. So I would not overestimate the level of civilization of a population whose majority appears unconcerned by what I see as such an obvious moral failure.

In my view, one of the roots of human barbarism is the tendency to overestimate either human nature itself or the moral achievements of one's own culture.

You are just too priviledge to understand people: many people would be glad do do it for the minimum wage, I would fight to have that oportunity (I live in west EU).