anon4711
Joined 10 years ago
Joined 10 years ago
I recall e.g. that Moxie reviewed Telegram's security, found that none of it made any sense and that its authors didn't know what they were doing. https://tobtu.com/decryptocat.php looks like the cryptocat analogue of that. Have the two projects improved somehow? Have some people joined or others left?
Could you please also provide links for the claim that CryptoCat and Telegram are being used by governments to hunt down activists?
> 2016-09-29T23:57:32Z Xach: I dropped com.informatimago because I do not want to have to discuss anything with pjb again. I have never enjoyed discussing anything previously, but his vile twitter feed drove me over the edge, and his project no longer builds, so I don't want to report problems or discuss solutions.
from here: http://ccl.clozure.com/irc-logs/lisp/lisp-2016-09.txt
The other matter is rehabilitation. Whether he should be allowed to apologise at some point, say that he made a mistake, and be welcomed back, is something that you cannot decide for everyone. It's up to your personal beliefs, in particular your religion. Everybody needs to determine that for him- or herself, in my opinion.
But a person cannot be both respectable and disrespectable at the same time, I find, although I'm afraid now we might be disagreeing rather about words than ideas. Respectability, to me, is a compliment to somebody's set of values.
edit: To make it more precise, full names are identical and http://www.informatimago.com/index.html links to http://pjb.ogamita.org which uses the same name (ogamita) as that twitter account.
Edit: I was replying to "But we have made surgery mistakes along the way". On a second reading, I notice that you did not actually mean to imply "it was necessary there so it's necessary here".
There might, however, be a dark side to the story. There is
a good reason we were designed to have finite sensitive
periods. Takao Hensch, a Harvard neuroscientist, has
written that plasticity takes a lot of energy: It’s
exhausting to keep all your neural circuits in a dynamic
state. Restricting it may protect the brain.
and in the paragraphs thereafter (I don't want to quote them here in full).