abolibibelot
Joined 16 years ago
Joined 16 years ago
The 1-star reviews roughly fall in three categories:
- This is not how proper projects are done.
- We don't need another cult-like methodology
- This will vindicate cow boy coders
2 and 3 may have a point.This school has its agile proponents too, though. But compared to the common practices of the penultimate decade, XP and Agile at least acknowledged that failure was the default mode of software development projects, and made contingency plans for it.
And on moonless nights I still wake up screaming remembering a RUP project I was involved in around 2000.
"No true scotsman" and all, I know.
The criticisms about no metrics supporting the book assertions are valid too (we have more metrics now, though).
That said, a lot of things in this book are now considered good engineering practices, and the methodology guys have come back with a vengeance with the Agile/Scrum/Lean/Whatever waves that filled the blanks left by XP (and ensured a nice revenue stream for pure process consultants).
Simple regular expressions can be good enough if you're aware of the domain restriction though.
Starship Trooper, the novel, is hilarious on its own, with its hawkishness and interesting political views (it's less creepy than Ender's Game in that aspect though). But Heinlein is a much better writer than Card and Stranger in a Strange land makes up for the juvenile tripe he wrote earlier. I guess Vietnam had to happen for some people to reflect on the Rah-rah-rah kind of military Sci-Fi.
(I know there's a cult of Heinlein on HN - I've always wondered if there was an intersection with the Cult of Rand and the Cult of Card)
Edit: as a thought experiment, it would be interesting (as in "depressing") to imagine the exact opposite: an adaptation of Old Man's War by the current Hollywood industry.
"Ruby is probably the best platform to learn if you're a designer and you want to learn how to code to add value for your clients."
and also I'd love some more details on why "Python is fairly mediocre in a lot of ways" (not starting a language war here, I'm genuinely curious)
(I'm in no way affiliated to Capitaine Train)