DemocracyFTW2

Joined 4 years ago

Karma
1,245
Submissions
1,324
Member since
May 2
View on Hacker News

Recent submissions

Comment · 15 hours ago
aren't you conflating "agentic engineering" with "agent engineering", i.e. "engineering that is based on the use of agents" with "the engineering of agents"? You wouldn't argue "good engineering" or "bad engineering" should be understood as "the engineering of good (things)" and "the engineering of bad (things)", would you?
Comment · 3 days ago
That's a sweet excuse until you understand that even state-owned nonprofits these days are run the way a harsh capitalist / neoliberal blood-sucking private-sector manager would run it. Because there very probably is a harsh capitalist / neoliberal blood-sucking public-sector manager running it.
Comment · 6 days ago
Be it said that in well-run countries voter fraud is so infrequent that neither voting machines nor "Biometric Voting Technology" are needed. Just use pen and paper and do a reasonable check on voter identity, like looking at their ID cards before voting. There is absolutely no need to go beyond this. With paper-based voting each vote produces a paper trail that is also the original voting document, a.k.a. the Source of Truth that answers the question "who did this anonymous person vote for?". When you do it with voting machines then either you have to use them to punch holes or make other marks on paper or cardboard, with which I'm by and large fine if nothing else is done. If a voting machine has counters or does data transmission in addition to marking a paper slip, things get much ickier: now you have several sources of truth and have to decide what to do if the counter or the manual recount is correct. Voting machines that work by only storing votes electronically are a complete disaster and should never be used.
Comment · 8 days ago
> this is copyright law. Might privacy be a separate matter?

It's not immediately clear to me but what is clear to me is that the intent of the law is to protect people that choose to surround their garden with a 3m impenetrable hedge (Tuia is popular for that). The law states you're free to admire the hedge but not free to climb a ladder to peer over it. If the same hedge gets cut down to 150cm, then the law states you're now free to admire the hedge and the garden and whatever you can make out form the house. In that case you may legally take a picture and if the angry house owner comes out jumping at you, well, bad luck for him. If you're carrying a selfie stick, that might change things.

As for Google Streetview cars, I'm normally of the opinion that when dealing with a corporation as big and powerful as this it's better to err on the side of caution and privacy. The blurring of facades tho I found totally unnecessary. Yes, the mount on top of the cars might be construed as a ladder. Also, the law was never written with a company taking photos at this scale in mind. OTOH when you actually use street view it generally does absolutely not look like the images were taken from an excessive height; for the most part I pretty much get to see what I would be able to see in person.

Comment · 8 days ago
Comment · 8 days ago
> Wealth taxes are inherently stupid in our modern financial system

"our modern financial system" is what is left of a reasonable but by now largely dismantled financial system that used to exist between roughly the 1930s and 1980s.

The entire phrase "Wealth taxes are inherently stupid in our modern financial system" has "throwing up my hands" and "there's nothing we can possibly do" written all over it. The financial system is a societal construct, not a natural constant like, say, the speed of light.

If not "wealth taxes", then what? Poverty taxes?

Comment · 12 days ago
the planet will be devoid of people on Tuesday, 5 May 3108

Der letzte macht das Licht aus.

Comment · 12 days ago
What does "talent engineering" even mean? And do they literally put people into cans? I have so many questions.
Comment · 12 days ago
> Drupal is used at large organizations with hundreds of sites, thousands of users, and multiple more-or-less coordinated development teams

Sadly none of this applies to me, so I wonder whether it makes a good argument when my question is "should I use Drupal for my personal hobby website".

Comment · 12 days ago
As someone who has recently started Pair Programming with LLMs—something I never managed to bring about with a human, sadly—I'd like to say: Sure you can do it. Sure, team up with a bunch of friends, a forest next door and build your dream cabin. Then compare that to a prefab from the Sears Modern Homes line. It's still 30'000 parts, 25 tons, est. 90 days build time, but it will be vastly easier, especially if one of your pals happens to be great at digging up and bringing together assembly instructions, general technical infos and past experiences from other builders for all the many snags you'll still hit when erecting that thing.

Can't answer the specifically "Drupal" part (as for me I once had a certain pressure behind me to use it, found it atrocious at the time and won't look to repeat that; if their software is much better / much more to my taste now, good on them). But in principle, at least from a certain app size upwards, I'd rather start with something working in principle, then improve on it.

That said, it might still be more difficult to get things right with Drupal than with some other softwares where you have better continuity between versions. At least traditional search engine results tend to handle version changes rather poorly meaning you'll get tons of advice that don't really apply anymore because they're years old. That happened a lot to me when trying to help out a friend with a WordPress installation.

Comment · 12 days ago
Like where, exactly?

As someone brighter than me put it, let's colonize Antarctica first. We're nowhere near being able to survive there, now, without regular support ships. Even with those, it would be considered a miserable existence by the vast majority of people. Tell me, where in the world would you go?

Comment · 12 days ago
This is tim333 not quite getting what the article is about.

> I imagine it'll be voluntary

But sure my sweet summer child, just come in and take a seat...

Comment · 12 days ago
> Cold, logical, emotionless machines that don't have identities

is exactly how people described those who did the dirty work in the concentration camps

Comment · 12 days ago
Should human beings remain in control of planet Earth? Or should we be replaced as the dominant species?

Without thinking too long or too hard I can most definitively think of some dominant individuals that should be replaced. As in, ASAP.

Comment · 13 days ago
Please DM me your place of birth so I can reply to this using the Form "Right, lets trust someone born in _________ (lol)". Lol.

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton