Arguggi

Joined 13 years ago

Karma
38
Submissions
14
Member since
Feb 24
Personal: https://arguggi.co.uk/blog/

Github Profile: https://github.com/Arguggi

View on Hacker News

Recent submissions

Comment · 11 years ago
Comment · 11 years ago
Comment · 11 years ago
Comment · 11 years ago
Comment · 11 years ago
Comment · 11 years ago
Comment · 11 years ago
Comment · 11 years ago
Comment · 12 years ago
Comment · 13 years ago
I agree that only answering "You just committed a fallacy, goodbye" would not be the right choice, but at least mentioning it and then try to explain why I think it's relevant doesn't seem so wrong.
Comment · 13 years ago
Am I the only one troubled by the last example?

And then suppose you encounter a woman who tells you that because of the insults she has received from guys in the skeptic community, she has decided that the skeptic movement is fundamentally sexist.

Receiving insults from men that identify as skeptics does not mean that the skeptic movement is fundamentally sexist.

Telling her she just committed a fallacy doesn't seem so wrong to me.

Comment · 13 years ago
Comment · 13 years ago
"So who governs what is the correct application and interpretation of data?"

Morozov doesn't worry about the correct application of data but, from what I understood reading the link, is more worried about this:

"Morozov fears a future in which such “intuitive knowledge” about how to deploy resources is overruled by algorithms that can work only with hard data and can’t, of course, account for the data they don’t have."

It could be argued that decisions based on "intuitive knowledge" without any data are as biased as the one's based on only data.

Comment · 13 years ago
"The solution proposed here is "Don't have data". Because if we stick our heads in a hole, it'll all get better?"

I don't think this is the solution Morozov is proposing. He's just saying that collecting and distributing more data will not necessarily be beneficial because data interpretation is subjective and data collection may be biased.

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton