Comment

Comment by unprepare

Let me get this straight:

>Communism is a subset of socialism

and

> Socialism always results in tyranny.

but your only examples of tyranny are from communist regimes.

Does that mean that:

> Square is a subset of rectangle

so

>rectangle always results in four right angles

given that my only examples of rectangles are squares?

Saying socialism /always/ does anything, and then listing only examples from a specific subset of socialism is plainly incorrect.

By your own admission:

>Humans will always create a hierarchy

Socialism could not have been tested, because it would require social ownership of the production of goods, and co-operative management of those resources. Hierarchy means they did not have co-operative management of resources, they had hierarchical management of resources.

parent unprepare 11 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton