Comment

Comment by Alkim

Well now I guess I have to do the math:

W = P(b)V(b) ln(P(a)/P(b))

(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compressed_air_energy_storage)

CPAP requires roughly 10 cm of water pressure = 0.01 Bar Sea level atmospheric pressure is roughly 1 bar So the device has to pressurize to 1.01 Bar Now I’ve looked it up, and a typical CPAP machine moves 20 to 60 liters per minute Let’s say 30 liters per minute = 1800 liters per hour

W = (1.007)(1.8)ln(1/1.007) = (1.81)*(-00698) = 0.0127 MJ = 3.53 Watt Hour

So assuming perfect efficiency you would still need 28.64 watt hours of battery, just to do the compression.

470 Wh/kg for Zinc-air battery implies this device requires a 60gm battery (2 oz to those of us of a certain age)

I looked up CPU fan efficiency (what they say they derived it from) and PEAK fan efficiency only approaches 25%

http://www.nmbtc.com/fans/white-papers/fan_efficiency_import...

So, you’d really need an 8 oz battery hanging from your nose to make this work, not counting what you need to run the electronics, etc.

parent Alkim 11 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton