Comment

Comment by avmich

Well, there could be some counterarguments.

> Allows you to get a mortgage

Wonder if that was always so? Didn't people manage somehow to have a house without something which name suggests it will be paid for the whole life?

> Allows you to protect yourself with health/car/life/home/title/etc insurance

A casino, right? On average you lose, but for a price you buy a hedge against unforeseen? At least unforeseen for you?

> Pays for your highways/stadiums/schools and other public works

I thought my taxes pay for that :) . Do you mean "finances" as "machinery which helps moving money"? I think there are several definitions there.

> Protects your deposits

That's great and helpful

> Pays for your retirement

Nah, that's those same deposits. I largely pay myself for retirement, by saving the whole life. There is also an element of "societal insurance", when I pay a little extra to help myself in case I suddenly become disabled. Or dead. Or, well, not so little; that depends.

> Funds the college fund that paid for your school

Again, it's either another example of "moving money", or an oddity - as people managed to get educated even without banks.

> ... Or the student loans that allowed you to attend school

Same thing.

> Supports the global supply chain that brings you your iPhone, stocks the grocery store/your favorite restaurants with food, and puts the clothes on your back.

Yes, that's another important role - bringing together lenders and borrowers, for a fee. One ought to assume the fee in the computerized XXI century should be small?

> Funds the growth of corporations large and small, giving you the job that allows you to buy an iPhone

Same thing. Banks don't "fund" - they "serve". Money aren't theirs, but theirs', banks', depositors.

> Funds the massive philanthropy expenditures that help those in need everyday

Talked about that already.

> Pays the pensions of the elderly

We already talked about that.

So, to boil down - banks provide money-related services, like "guarding" deposits (you pay for the privilege) or "investing" deposit money (you ought to share risks and benefits). Other than that...

parent avmich 11 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton