Comment

Comment by frig

I'm partially defending list comprehensions here and partially challenging you to consider the possibility that there are higher levels of abstraction out there than those employed by functional programming primitives like map and filter.

Level 0: for-loops with an explicit accumulator

Level 1: map + filter (!)

Level 2: ??? arguably an atemporal set-theoretic approach

In practice in python list comprehensions are a superior syntax for computing with multiple source collections.

(!) Really all you need is reduce

    map = lambda f,l: reduce(lambda h,t: h + f(t), l, [])
    filter = lambda f,l: reduce(lambda h,t: h + t if f(t) else h, l, [])
You'd be silly to implement them that way of course but know your tools.
parent frig 17 years ago

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts.

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton