Comment

Comment by graycat

High level question: Why do we need to care about such things? Or, what's wrong with just HTML and just some simple usage of old CSS3 or whatever it was? That is, why do Web pages need to be so complicated? Since we have decades of word whacking software without such features, why do we need such features now?

My Web pages are all really simple: Each is 800 pixels wide, with just a little use of CSS and then nearly all just HTML, with the layout using tables. I have yet to write a single line of JavaScript although Microsoft's ASP.NET writes a little for me.

To me, my Web pages look quite functional, usable, easy to understand and use, etc.

For the need for a lot more, I don't get it and worse: On the Internet I see a lot of really complicated Web pages that jump around while loading and then again when I use my mouse to put the page into the focus and use the scroll wheel on the mouse to scroll the page. I don't like the jumping around.

Why go to the trouble to build such complicated Web pages?

I'm not criticizing but trying to learn and inviting answers.

Why bother? HTML was just another text markup language, and nice, and CSS helped a little. Isn't that enough?

I learned some HTML, and it was fine, and now I want to move on and just use it and not stop here and make a career out of adding unbounded complexity.

Shouldn't things be as simple as possible but not simpler? Why be so complicated? To me, the complicated Web pages I see are a disaster, slow down my computer, etc. -- I'd much rather have just simple Web pages with old HTML, only simple CSS, and little or no JavaScript.

parent graycat 12 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton