At a previous job, we built a proof-of-concept Sinatra service (i.e., HTTP/RESTful service) that would, on a certain API call, clone from a specified snapshot, and also create an iscsi target to that new clone. This was on OpenIndiana initially, then some other variant of that OS as a second attempt.
The client making the HTTP request was IPXE; so, every time the machine booted, you'd get yourself a flesh clone + iscsi target and we'd then mount that ISCSI target in IPXE, which would then hand off the ISCSI target to the OS and away you'd go.
The fundamental problem we hit was that there was a linear delay for every new clone; the delay seemed to be 'number of clones * .05 second' or so. This was on extremely fast hardware. It was the ZFS command to clone that was going to slowly.
Around 500 clones, we'd notice these 10/20 second delays. The reason that hurt so bad is that, to our understanding, it wasn't safe to do ZFS commands or ISCSI commands in a parallel manner; the Sinatra service was responsible for serializing all ZFS/ISCSI commands.
So my question to the author:
1) Does this 'delay per clones' ring familiar to you? Does ZFS on Linux have the same issue? It was a killer for us, and I found a thread eventually that implied it would not ever get fixed in Solaris-land.
2) Can you execute concurrent ZFS CLI commands on the OS? Or is that dangerous like we found it to be on Solaris?
The client making the HTTP request was IPXE; so, every time the machine booted, you'd get yourself a flesh clone + iscsi target and we'd then mount that ISCSI target in IPXE, which would then hand off the ISCSI target to the OS and away you'd go.
The fundamental problem we hit was that there was a linear delay for every new clone; the delay seemed to be 'number of clones * .05 second' or so. This was on extremely fast hardware. It was the ZFS command to clone that was going to slowly.
Around 500 clones, we'd notice these 10/20 second delays. The reason that hurt so bad is that, to our understanding, it wasn't safe to do ZFS commands or ISCSI commands in a parallel manner; the Sinatra service was responsible for serializing all ZFS/ISCSI commands.
So my question to the author:
1) Does this 'delay per clones' ring familiar to you? Does ZFS on Linux have the same issue? It was a killer for us, and I found a thread eventually that implied it would not ever get fixed in Solaris-land.
2) Can you execute concurrent ZFS CLI commands on the OS? Or is that dangerous like we found it to be on Solaris?