Comment

Comment by themartorana

> Please think for a minute in your web activities, you will get to realize that you are not roaming the internet but instead you are roaming Google Services and many others served by Google Services. Please think for a minute in Google Search, Gmail, YouTube, Blogger, Google+, Analytics, AdSense, AdWords, Docs, Drive, Chrome, Maps, Hangouts, and Talk etc...

This is an argument I see a lot - just think and you will realize how right I am. It is often used in place of an evidence-based argument and is an appeal TO your logical brain FROM someone's emotional brain.

It always makes me uncomfortable, because it's not far from "search your heart/feelings" - the basis of any logic- or evidence-free argument. It also seems to have the negative undertone of "if you DON'T agree with me, you obviously can't "think" on my level."

It's not that there isn't evidence of Google being less-than savory - I would argue there is - but I'd research that argument first, not just appeal for emotional sympathies.

parent themartorana 12 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton