Ars's headline is inaccurate. These are the licensing terms for Google's closed-source suite of ecosystem apps that turn a generic AOSP-based port into a Google-logo commercial product.
The restrictions stem from a choice you have to make: If you use the Google ecosystem in your products, you have to use all of it, and you can't use parts of Android to compete with the Google ecosystem. You can make the other choice, but, in those cases, Google doesn't want you to have their closed, proprietary apps. That might be hard-nosed dealing, but it isn't more restrictive than Google's competitors are in similar circumstances.
There are some seemingly nonsensical parts to the agreement, especially the prohibition against distributing an SDK derived from the Android SDK. I'm having a difficult time imagining what harm that might cause. Some OEMs, like Samsung, are shipping SDK extensions that Google apparently is fine with.
The openness of AOSP is not compromised by this contract. Amazon is an example of a partly direct competitor using AOSP. Google has done nothing to thwart Amazon, not even a hint of FUD. If only Oracle were that straightforward about Java.
The restrictions stem from a choice you have to make: If you use the Google ecosystem in your products, you have to use all of it, and you can't use parts of Android to compete with the Google ecosystem. You can make the other choice, but, in those cases, Google doesn't want you to have their closed, proprietary apps. That might be hard-nosed dealing, but it isn't more restrictive than Google's competitors are in similar circumstances.
There are some seemingly nonsensical parts to the agreement, especially the prohibition against distributing an SDK derived from the Android SDK. I'm having a difficult time imagining what harm that might cause. Some OEMs, like Samsung, are shipping SDK extensions that Google apparently is fine with.
The openness of AOSP is not compromised by this contract. Amazon is an example of a partly direct competitor using AOSP. Google has done nothing to thwart Amazon, not even a hint of FUD. If only Oracle were that straightforward about Java.