Comment

Comment by Maria1987

Just a short note on the "we do not understand the brain and thus are not able to design more sophisticated methods to treat this terrible decease"

Allow me to disagree.

We do not need to understand how the brain works in order to be able to find treatments for all the different mental deceases.

Its all trials and errors, hypothesis -> testing -> result, again and again and again until a final conclusion!

I have spend a lot of years researching the brain, the black box which everyone wants to understand but no-one has any clue about it and more specifically Alzheimer's disease (not in a pharmaceutical company but in academia).

From my experience, we don't need to understand how something works if we know what is the most likely outcome for a given input.

I was lucky enough to test different types of drugs, their long term and short term effects, how useful they are and of course what effects have in behaviour etc. From every single study I could put a piece of puzzle right there and be able to see a clearer picture of what's going on, make hypothesis, tests hypotheses, have controls, tests controls etc. I obviously have no clue how the brain works but for those things I checked I know:

Given an input -> Brain -> I get an particular output most likely*

From that (and of course many control studies), I could trust that this drugs will most likely give me the predicted output. And that's how research is done..Is not always correct but based on that, we managed to be where we are, to have drugs for diseases which in the past killed us and step by step we can move forward and it would be wrong to doubt how much improvement has been done so far by the research community.

I am not suggesting you to trust anti-psychotic, just suggesting you that in my personal opinion, is wrong not trusting a drug (which you of course are well aware for advantages/ disadvantages) just because you don't know how brain works...Many other drugs which are for simple diseases actually affect your brain in many similar ways as anti-psychotics.

parent Maria1987 13 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton