Comment

Comment by lucb1e

> Team Chat That Doesn't Suck

IRC?

I use IRC for all sorts of purposes and audiences, there are tens ifnot hundreds of implementations that are being actively maintained, and it's been a standard for decades. How does that suck?

Edit: Oh they mention "Like IRC, but smarter", where smarter is a link. Let's see about that.

> Know who's seen any message.

Facebook does this. It more annoys me than anything else, but I can see the point. People could also simply acknowledge having read something, but again, ok I see the point.

> Edit messages after you've sent them.

Depends on the audience... On Skype (1 on 1 chat) it rocks, StackExchange's chat is generally not for 13-year-olds either so there it works as well, but in most team chats I wouldn't want this feature. Since it's aimed at Github users, I suppose this is a nice feature.

> Automatically embeds content like YouTube, pictures of cats and other stuff.

God no.

> Did we mention our smart notifications? @mentions. Batched notifications. Won't annoy you by making your phone beep on every message.

IRC, IRC and IRC.

> Awesome emotigifs.

You mean like MSN's Winks®? [1]

> Infinite chat history stored in the cloud.

trustworthiness--;

> Searchable too, naturally.

grep

> Oh, and a unified activity feed.

Hmm, what's that for? You mean like IRC clients' "last message" feature, or a way that stalks people even when your client is not running?

[1] http://img.uptodown.net/screen/windows/bigthumb/free-msn-win...

parent lucb1e 13 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton