Comment

Comment by PeterisP

If they send a https password reset/create link, then the password is never transmitted in the clear and nobody knows it. In the case of an email snooper getting access to the password-reset link and clicking it before me, I would immediately know that there's an attack because, well, the password was reset to something different from what I entered, and I'd receive a notification about that, too.

If they generate and send a plaintext password, then anyone who gets access to that email, even months in future, can silently access the account. So there is a difference.

Also, the whole concept of having a cleartext password sent unencrypted anywhere at all clearly violates PCI DSS requirements - and it is Ayden's duty to comply and be knowledgeable about that.

There's not a question of good/bad service quality, it raises a question if they're meeting the bare minimum criteria to be allowed in payment business at all.

parent PeterisP 13 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton