Comment

Comment by steveklabnik

> (Ironically, a check that was bad because of the fee taken for 'a')

This is a real big problem in these kinds of situations.

To give you an idea of how this happens: when I was in college, I worked at a pizza shop. It was Thursday. I got paid Friday. I thought I had $20 in my bank account, but I didn't realize that day was the day that my World of Warcraft subscription was up, and that was $15. During the course of the day, I bought lunch, a snack, and some pencils or something. All that total was less than the $20, it was something like $10 for lunch, $2 for the snack, and $5 for the pencils. So I was good.

I wans't good. They applied the charges like this:

  Starting Balance: $20 
  WoW:             -$15 
  ---------------------
                    $ 5
  Lunch:            $10
  ---------------------
                   -$ 5
  Overdraft fee:   -$35
  ---------------------
                   -$40
  Snack:           -$ 2
  ---------------------
                   -$42
  Overdraft fee:   -$35
  ---------------------
                   -$77
  Pencils:         -$ 5
  ---------------------
                   -$82
  Overdraft fee:   -$35
  ---------------------
  End total:      -$117
Now, what sucks is that if they had processed them in a different order, it would have looked like this:

  Starting Balance: $20
  Lunch:            $10
  --------------------- 
                    $10 
  Snack:           -$ 2 
  --------------------- 
                    $ 8 
  Pencils:         -$ 5 
  --------------------- 
                    $ 3 
  WoW:             -$15 
  --------------------- 
                   -$12
  Overdraft fee:   -$35
  ---------------------
  End total:       -$47

Still an expensive mistake on my part, but it's more subtle than 'made a bad choice.' I was able to convince the bank to refund two of the fees so I was only out $40, but that extra $70 was a _massive_ amount of money to me at the time. It basically meant that I could only exactly squeak by for the next month, since that was basically all of my discretionary income. You can construct a similar situation which would have forced me to then take out a payday loan to make my bills, had I made one or two more mistakes in that same timeframe.
parent steveklabnik 13 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton