Comment

Comment by chiph

America is both rich & poor at the same time. We have one of the most productive and efficient workforces on the planet, yet we are $17 trillion in debt. This can only be because we spent our money poorly - making bad decisions about where it should go.

That debt can only be retired if we have a plan to stop increasing it, and to make payments to reduce the principal. The article says that the BIG would do this, but provides no rationale as to how this might happen. Would the BIG replace the myriad existing income programs? I don't see how - $10k is $834 a month, which not much more than the monthly food bill for a family. It would be to their advantage to continue on the old programs, as they'd get more money each month.

The other danger is that the $10k wouldn't stay $10k for very long. Soon, there would be impassioned pleas from the politicians that "We have to help these people" by increasing it to provide a living wage.

parent chiph 13 years ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton