Yeah, they all have one quirk or another which seems to make the app your trying to work on impossible. For me, it was always the integration of async event loops w/ the widget framework.
As for the decade old roast, theres a few things I disagree with.
...
Using Qt, one would write:
auto widget = new QWidget{parent};
widget->show();
2 lines, all obvious, all working as expected.
...
No. It's 2 lines, which makes it "not at all obvious." Those 2 lines have so much baked in functionality, I have no idea what its doing until I read 100 pages of documentation and become an "expert" on the internals of that specific UI toolkit.
...
But let’s go into some details. Remember the quote about types? EFL takes that philosophy seriously. Everything is a pointer to something called Evas_Object, which translates to void *. Those knowledgeable in the horrible language of C know it’s a pointer to anything. And so it is.
...
Okay, now we see where the motivation to roast comes from. This guy hates the C language itself, so he's going to hate any GUI toolkit coded in C.
Theres no argument from me that C's syntax makes coding GUIs based on object hierarchies more difficult than languages with proper OO support, but the alternatives have their own problems as well.
At the end of the day, its good to have choices.
As for the decade old roast, theres a few things I disagree with.
...
Using Qt, one would write:
auto widget = new QWidget{parent}; widget->show();
2 lines, all obvious, all working as expected.
...
No. It's 2 lines, which makes it "not at all obvious." Those 2 lines have so much baked in functionality, I have no idea what its doing until I read 100 pages of documentation and become an "expert" on the internals of that specific UI toolkit.
...
But let’s go into some details. Remember the quote about types? EFL takes that philosophy seriously. Everything is a pointer to something called Evas_Object, which translates to void *. Those knowledgeable in the horrible language of C know it’s a pointer to anything. And so it is.
...
Okay, now we see where the motivation to roast comes from. This guy hates the C language itself, so he's going to hate any GUI toolkit coded in C.
Theres no argument from me that C's syntax makes coding GUIs based on object hierarchies more difficult than languages with proper OO support, but the alternatives have their own problems as well.
At the end of the day, its good to have choices.