Comment

Comment by amluto

While heating something that hot using “passive” components (is a laser really passive?) is awesome, is it really useful? 5500K is considerably hotter that, say, the combustion chamber of a rocket, and those chambers need active cooling. And even 1500K is plenty hot that the Carnot efficiency of the heat engine part will be high.

Also, a solar pumped laser needs cooling, just like a heat engine! Just from first principles, you can’t have a gadget at thermal equilibrium that magically produces an excess of light at its output frequency — this would violate the second law of thermodynamics.

And if you imagine a model three-level laser, exposing all three transitions to bright light will pump the nonlasing intermediate transition (overfilling level 2, thus reducing the population inversion in a laser lasing on the 3 -> 2 transition, or pumping useful level 2 atoms back up to level 3 in a laser lasing on 2 -> 1) and will actively un-pump the lasing transition in any variety of laser (because light in the wrong mode will cause a population-inverted transition to emit into that same wrong mode by simulated emission).

parent amluto 12 hours ago

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts.

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton