Comment

Comment by hardbass

What do you think a Chinese room is? You may be using this in a different way than the argument was meant, and a different way a reasonable interpretation of the experiment would be (which is different to it's authors viewpoint).

Yes and what you are saying is sense organs? To an llm twxt input is a sense organ, these days they can also read images and videos. I am not very sure what it means to not feel something, pregnancy like any experience or memory is a data, most of it should be in our brain while some of it would be interactions of the brain with the rest of the body. Even independently of this, there is no reason to think something trained on human written text from the human pov won't in its raw form (before rlhf.or whatver) think itslef as human and experience humna or human like emotions.

The collection of tokens argument sounds strange to me, do you think brains don't store data as electrical and chemical states?

parent hardbass 2 days ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton