Comment

Comment by cyberax

> Have the router issue ULAs only and let the router do stateless NPT (network prefix translation) only.

This is an option, but ULAs are ranked _below_ IPv4 in address selection preferences. So your network will essentially operate in IPv4 mode: https://www.ietf.org/archive/id/draft-buraglio-6man-rfc6724-...

Moreover, some devices will refuse to connect to IPv6 GUA with ULA addresses altogether.

> Yes, your local devices will use the ULA to attempt to connect to Internet destinations if that’s the only v6 address they have. It works fine.

You're half right. The devices will work fine because they won't be using IPv6 at all.

As I said, IPv6 is a recursive WTF.

How do I know that? I made a personal goal to create a dualstack demo network that is fully standards compliant and supports the bare minimum functionality that I would expect from a SOHO network. So far, I keep finding new and exciting breakages on every level.

parent cyberax 15 days ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton