Comment

Comment by kccqzy

It’s a standard way to do pre and post conditions. Clojure pre and post conditions also behave this way. If you force these conditions into compile-time checks, well, then you are introducing a second type system with refinement types into the language. And type checking would take a long time. Imagine someone writes a precondition for a function where its integer argument x needs to satisfy collatz(x)==1; do you now expect the compiler to prove the collatz conjecture or verify it for all 64-bit integers every compilation?

My experience using pre and post conditions in Clojure makes me really like them. They are a small but meaningful improvement over plain old assertions. And yes being able to turn them off is a feature not a bug. Don’t expect them to be like LiquidHaskell.

parent kccqzy 17 days ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton