Every human culture thinks that nothing should be done to save the deer from the wolves or interfere in the food chain of intact ecosystems. Those that have them have different ideas for pets which are ‘members of the household’ as Kant put it. There is no unreason in this. And hunter gather cultures have still others for hunting quarry ; pastoral peoples others for eg the sheep they move from hilltop to hilltop as distinct from the dogs who assist. None of these distinctions have a trace of hypocrisy nor do they need rationalization.
The bourgeois factory farm is a menace but because of the usual competitive drive that showed in Dickens time leading to eg child labor and 16 hour days - but which here has no one to rebel and it’s all hidden by the separation of production and consumption. The operative principles, market and competition, are near universally praised.
This quite particular hyper capitalistic system is the origin also of the sentimentalist point of view you think opposes it by erasing distinctions and ignoring structures — it is a point of view which necessarily calls us depraved for leaving the wolves and deer in peace. It is clear that deer are perfectly conscious and suffer but also that the nature in which wolves eat them is inviolable. This involves no rationalization but is simply the truth.
The bourgeois factory farm is a menace but because of the usual competitive drive that showed in Dickens time leading to eg child labor and 16 hour days - but which here has no one to rebel and it’s all hidden by the separation of production and consumption. The operative principles, market and competition, are near universally praised.
This quite particular hyper capitalistic system is the origin also of the sentimentalist point of view you think opposes it by erasing distinctions and ignoring structures — it is a point of view which necessarily calls us depraved for leaving the wolves and deer in peace. It is clear that deer are perfectly conscious and suffer but also that the nature in which wolves eat them is inviolable. This involves no rationalization but is simply the truth.