> this is not reliant on just extrapolating existing theories but actually shows novel/surprising approaches
"Surprising" is a, well, surprisingly high bar to clear, and requires thorough understanding of not only the paper, but existing work in the area. ("Novel" is tautological.)
How did you determine this in 1 hour? Are you a researcher in multiple of these areas?
Can you give an example, or explain more how you came to this conclusion?
"Surprising" is a, well, surprisingly high bar to clear, and requires thorough understanding of not only the paper, but existing work in the area. ("Novel" is tautological.)
How did you determine this in 1 hour? Are you a researcher in multiple of these areas?
Can you give an example, or explain more how you came to this conclusion?