I have no problem with someone having a position like:
Conscious is a field phenomenon caused by the brain. GPUs can't induce these fields. So LLMs can't be conscious.
Or
Conscious arises from some quantum physical effect that GPUs can't do. So LLMs can't be conscious.
Or
God made man with a soul, spirit and body and He didn't give these to LLMs.
But in these cases at least the position is understandable.
I don't see what point she is making (besides philosophers being cleverer that they are given credit for and LLMs are clearly not conscious and her little flow chart of questions somehow will convince people their thinking is unclear and muddled and incoherent)
Conscious is a field phenomenon caused by the brain. GPUs can't induce these fields. So LLMs can't be conscious.
Or
Conscious arises from some quantum physical effect that GPUs can't do. So LLMs can't be conscious.
Or
God made man with a soul, spirit and body and He didn't give these to LLMs.
But in these cases at least the position is understandable.
I don't see what point she is making (besides philosophers being cleverer that they are given credit for and LLMs are clearly not conscious and her little flow chart of questions somehow will convince people their thinking is unclear and muddled and incoherent)