Comment

Comment by ben_w

There's a lot of different designs besides this one.

So far as I can work out, literally all of the plans are bad. The "why" varies, but they're all bad.

I'm too tired to double check your maths, so I will assume correct: one likely difference even for this plan is a terminator following sun-synchronous orbit, which means you'll only see it twice a day despite the orbital period being about 90-100 minutes, and when you see it will be specifically at sunrise and sunset.

Visibility is also a question of reflection, not just size. Terminator following orbits are worse than normal satellites, because one of the tricks for reducing e.g. Starlink visibility is to tilt them as they cross the terminator and you can't do that if they're always on the terminator.

The SpaceX plans (a million small ones) becomes a glitter band in some parts of the sky and will appear visually contiguous in other parts, though I need to double check my maths and assumptions about visibility given this happens during sunrise and sunset so the sky itself is pretty bright.

parent ben_w 1 month ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton