Comment

Comment by bluegatty

'Software' is about understanding problems and designing solutions along those dimensions.

But 'coding' per sey is 100% solved by LLMs - they write compiler perfect code all the time.

The question is not 'what it writes'.

The LLM is like a writer's assistant, who has perfect prose and grammar, but doesn't really write 'stories'.

""The reason LLMs are successful in writing code is because we’ve made a feedback loop that feeds the syntax/runtime errors back to the LLM and loops until most errors are solved or hidden."""

No - LLMs are 'good at code' because they have been ultimately 'trained' by the compiler.

All of the various SFT/RLHF methods etc. are using the compiler as the verifier.

parent bluegatty 1 month ago

Discussion

Live from the official Hacker News API

A modern reader for Hacker News · SvelteKit + Skeleton