>This ended up hurting me because object initialization touched three separate cache lines (obvious in hindsight, but the advice of using SoA failed me here).
I mean this is kind of what happens with any advice that has nuance to it, that's not carried with the advice.
E.g. if you have a point in 3D space with x, y, z coordinates. Array points as SoA of individual dimensions makes sense only if you do a lot of averaging and such on the individual dimensions.
If you mostly use the 3 coordinates together, SoA will have bad caching behavior.
So the better advice would be to try to keep things that are used together in the same cache line, whether it's on dimension or all 3. Usage makes the difference.
I mean this is kind of what happens with any advice that has nuance to it, that's not carried with the advice.
E.g. if you have a point in 3D space with x, y, z coordinates. Array points as SoA of individual dimensions makes sense only if you do a lot of averaging and such on the individual dimensions.
If you mostly use the 3 coordinates together, SoA will have bad caching behavior.
So the better advice would be to try to keep things that are used together in the same cache line, whether it's on dimension or all 3. Usage makes the difference.